UPI’s Pricing Reckoning: Designing a Sustainable Payments Network
UPI Doesn’t Have to Be Free. It Has to Be Fair.
When a customer scans a QR code at a neighbourhood shop, the payment looks almost effortless. Behind that scan are banks, payment apps, fraud controls, reconciliation systems and support teams. The customer doesn’t need to see any of that. But someone has to pay for it.
A recent analysis by Sriram Kalyanaraman makes a useful distinction: UPI has been free at the point of use for many people, not free to operate. The debate over a merchant discount rate (MDR)-a fee on merchant payments-brings those costs into view. It also raises a harder question: will the fee pay for a better network, or mainly reward those who already dominate it?
Pricing is part of the architecture
As an architect, I think of a fee as a routing rule for behaviour. A merchant who accepts a ₹75,000 payment over UPI today may ask for a bank transfer tomorrow if the two methods carry materially different costs. A shop that can’t recover GST on the fee may raise prices across the board, even if it never adds a surcharge at checkout. Neither outcome shows up in the payment API, but both are consequences of its design.
The same logic applies to the institutions running the network. If revenue follows transaction volume, the largest apps earn the most. That may be defensible where it reflects the cost of serving more users. It is harder to justify if the payment per transaction stays constant even as those costs fall with scale. UPI’s interoperability lets customers on different apps pay one another. It does not, by itself, give a smaller app a fair chance of becoming the one people open first.
Pay for the work the network needs
Before settling on a rate, I would ask banks, payment operators and apps to show what it costs to keep UPI reliable. How much goes into handling peak loads, resolving failed payments and disputes, and preventing fraud? Which costs rise with each transaction, and which are shared across the network? Without audited answers, even a modest fee is difficult to defend: we can see what merchants pay, but not what the network gets in return.
That’s also why I would put rate-setting with the RBI rather than leave it to an operator owned by institutions that receive a share of the fee. Publish who gets paid, review the rate periodically, and consider a declining per-transaction share for apps at higher volumes where the cost evidence supports it. The objective is to fund the work participants actually do without turning today’s market share into a permanent advantage.
Design for the merchant at the last mile
In parts of Northeast India, a small merchant may already have to reconcile cash and digital receipts when connectivity is intermittent. A predictable fee, a clear settlement record, and a straightforward way to resolve a failed payment matter more to that merchant than a rate that looks competitive in an international comparison.
Protecting small merchants therefore means more than keeping most transactions free by count. It means adjusting exemptions as prices rise, holding acquiring banks accountable for improper surcharges, and treating a loan repayment differently from a retail purchase. A borrower who was encouraged to move away from cash should not face a new charge simply for repaying digitally.
For CTOs and founders building on India’s digital public infrastructure, the lesson goes beyond payments: the rules for funding a shared system shape who can afford to use it, who can compete on top of it, and who is accountable when it fails. Those rules deserve as much design attention as the APIs.
UPI earned trust by making payments simple. Its funding model should be just as easy to understand and defend.
About the Author: Sanjeev Sarma is the Founder Director and Chief Software Architect at Webx Technologies. With a core focus on Generative AI integration, Cloud-Native Scalability, and Enterprise Software Architecture, he has spent over two decades driving digital transformation across Northeast India and beyond. Beyond his corporate leadership, Sanjeev is deeply invested in shaping the future of the IT industry. He serves as an Industry Expert on the Board of Studies for Assam Don Bosco University’s School of Technology, advises state technology committees, and actively mentors emerging tech startups at STPI. He brings a unique, dual perspective of high-level enterprise execution and future-ready academic curriculum development.