In a significant ruling on ancestral property rights, the Supreme Court of India has held that a grandson cannot claim any share in his grandfather’s property during his father’s lifetime under the Hindu Succession Act. Delivering the verdict, a bench comprising Justice Augustine George Masih and Justice Sunita Agarwal clarified that an individual who inherits property from their father becomes its absolute owner. Consequently, such an owner possesses complete authority over the property and can even choose to exclude their own son from it.
The judgment brings a definitive conclusion to a 29-year-long legal battle that began in 1997, when a son approached the court seeking a share in his father’s property, claiming it was ancestral and belonged to a joint Hindu family. Rejecting the claim, the apex court cited Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, emphasizing that property inherited by a male from his father vests in him exclusively as separate property, and his male descendants do not acquire any birthright in it.
The bench further elaborated that under the Hindu Succession Act, a grandson does not qualify as a Class I legal heir while his father is alive. Because the schedule of Class I heirs does not include a grandson whose father survives, he holds no legal standing to demand partition or ownership in the grandfather’s estate. The court noted that Class I legal heirs inherit the estate simultaneously, thereby excluding all other distant relatives from asserting claims during their lifetime.
Addressing the broader interpretation of the 1956 statute, the Supreme Court affirmed that Section 8 is a standalone provision governing the distribution of property belonging to a Hindu male who dies without leaving a will. Under these statutory provisions, personal law grants no inherent entitlement to grandchildren over their grandfather’s estate while their father remains alive, reinforcing the absolute ownership rights of immediate successors.
Original Source: https://assam.nenow.in/supreme-court-ancestral-property-ruling-says-a-grandson-cannot-claim-a-share-in-his-grandfathers-property-while-his-father-is-alive/
Category: Popular Stories,দেশ,শীর্ষ সংবাদ
Tags:
Publish Date: 2026-11-11 14:27:00
