সংসদৰ আইন প্ৰণয়ন বনাম ন্যায়ালয়ৰ সম্মান: পুনৰ তীব্ৰ বিতৰ্ক
On Tuesday a bench headed by Justices Manoj Mishra and Vijay Bishnoi of the Supreme Court agreed to hear a challenge to the Central Armed Police Forces or General Administration Act, 2026, issuing notice to the central government. The petitioners say the new law defeats a May 23, 2025 Supreme Court order that had directed a phased reduction in Indian Police Service (IPS) appointments to senior posts in the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF), and they contend the statute raises a fundamental constitutional question about whether Parliament can negate a court’s directive through legislation.
The petition was filed by 34 serving CAPF officers and more than 3,000 Group A cadre officers. They argue that Section 3 of the 2026 Act empowers the central government to frame appointment and promotion rules even after a court order, and that the law reserves a large share of senior CAPF posts for IPS officers — reportedly 50 percent of Inspector General (IG) posts, 67 percent of Additional Director General (ADG) posts, and 100 percent of Director General (DG) and Special DG posts. According to the petitioners, this effectively nullifies the Supreme Court’s earlier direction and restores the previous arrangement that limited promotion opportunities for CAPF cadre officers.
The dispute traces back to Sanjay Prakash v. Union of India, decided on May 23, 2025, in which the Supreme Court said IPS representation in top CAPF positions should be progressively reduced within two years to open promotion avenues for CAPF officers and increase their role in administrative decision‑making. Petitioners now argue that while Parliament may amend laws, it cannot overturn the core reasoning of a judicial judgment in a way that infringes constitutional guarantees under Articles 14 (equality), 16 (equal opportunity in public employment) and 21 (protection of life and personal liberty).
The filings also cite a 2019 Supreme Court ruling that recognized CAPF as an organized Group A central civil service, contending that the new law cannot strip away that status or its consequences for cadre progression. The conflict revives a decades‑long grievance: CAPF officers say IPS appointments to senior posts block their promotion trajectories and disadvantage officers who have spent their careers in the forces, while the government maintains that the administrative experience of IPS officers is essential to lead and manage large paramilitary forces.
The Supreme Court’s forthcoming judgment will not only shape the future leadership and promotion structure within the CAPF but is also likely to clarify the limits of Parliament’s power to legislate in circumstances where its laws appear to conflict with judicial directions — a matter now closely watched across the country.
Original Source: https://assam.nenow.in/why-the-latest-challenge-to-capf-act-is-about-more-than-ips-deputation/
Category: দেশ,শীর্ষ সংবাদ
Tags:
Publish Date: 2026-08-06 09:08:00