Sikkim High Court Dismisses Plea Challenging Protocol O Termination
The High Court of Sikkim in Gangtok has dismissed a writ petition by Smriti Chettri challenging her termination as Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer, with Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque ruling that her appointment was illegal and void from the outset. In the judgment delivered on November 16, the court found multiple violations: an experience certificate accepted after the deadline, appointment beyond the single advertised vacancy, and breach of mandatory recruitment rules.
The vacancy was advertised on November 3, 2025, with November 15, 2025, as the last date for applications. Chettri’s application was initially rejected for lack of the required experience certificate, but she submitted the document on November 18-three days after the deadline-and was then allowed to appear for the interview on November 19. The selection list published on November 25 named Araprita Das, Smriti Chettri and Ravi Eshan Tamang. After the interview, the then Chief Justice converted two Lower Division Assistant-cum-Typist posts into Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer posts through a notification dated November 21, 2025, and the three candidates were selected and appointed.
The Full Court on April 21, 2026, however, decided to terminate Chettri’s service because her appointment exceeded the one vacancy originally advertised. The termination order was issued on July 16, 2026. Rejecting her claim that she had been selected on merit and could be accommodated against later-created vacancies, the court relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Rakhi Ray and Others v. High Court of Delhi and Others (2010) 2 SCC 637. Recruitment beyond notified vacancies, the judgment said, violates Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution.
The court also held that accepting Chettri’s experience certificate after the cut-off date effectively extended the deadline in her favour, breaching the level playing field. It found a further violation of Rule 6 of the High Court of Sikkim (Recruitment, Conditions of Service and Conduct) Rules, 1998, which requires direct recruitment through a competitive examination prescribed by the Chief Justice. The court said this requirement was mandatory and could not be bypassed using residuary powers under Rules 14 and 19. Selection solely through viva-voce, it added, lacked transparency and raised serious concerns about nepotism.
Although the Chief Justice has power under Article 229 to create posts, appointments against newly created posts required State Government sanction under Rule 13 of the Sikkim Government Establishment Rules, 1974, the court held. It rejected pleas for equitable relief, stating: “Sympathy cannot legitimize illegality, nor can any right flow from a wrong.”
The Chief Justice observed that the case was not isolated but part of other appointments allegedly made in violation of legal requirements over the preceding two years. The High Court, the judgment said, is the guardian of the rule of law and must act as a model employer to preserve public confidence. The court noted that Chettri had previously worked in the State Government and that her probation in the High Court had not been declared; since she had not become a full member of the High Court service, she was given liberty to pursue any lawful remedy concerning her lien in her previous employment.
Original Source: https://www.sikkimexpress.com/news-details/sikkim-high-court-dismisses-plea-challenging-termination-of-protocol-officer
Category:
Tags:
Publish Date: