Exclusive Buzz: South Korea’s Major Probe Into Underage K-Pop Stars’ Rights Unveiled-What Secrets Will Be Exposed?
Seoul’s K-pop glitter has a shadow, and it is shaped like a contract. Rupaliparda here, and the boardroom should be squirming: the South Korean government has finally decided to look under the sequinned rock, announcing its first comprehensive survey of underage entertainers in 2027 and a review of the industry’s standard contracts.
The trigger? A November 5 New York Times investigation into the exclusive agreements NewJeans signed with Ador, a Hybe subsidiary, back in 2022. All five members were minors-aged 14 to 17-when they put pen to paper. And what a paper it was, according to the report: provisions requiring the girls to bear a substantial slice of trainee-year expenses, including cosmetic surgery and dermatological treatments; clauses letting the agency keep using their names, likenesses and voices after the contract ends, AI-generated content included; broad restrictions on personal conduct, from work attitude to romantic relationships and personal management; and a termination-penalty formula that could cost more than the government’s own standard contract.
Cue the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism, which on November 16 said it takes the concerns seriously and will examine whether existing rules properly protect underage performers’ rights to education, rest and sleep. The survey will establish how many underage artists are represented by agencies, their ages, and whether their basic rights are respected. Scope and methodology? Still being finalised-which in industry-speak means the fine print is being fought over. Kim Yu-mi, director of the ministry’s Popular Culture Industry Division, said a separate survey will properly assess the situation, with expanded psychological counselling and legal advisory services, plus a review of whether the standard contracts need improvement.
Hybe and Ador, predictably, are not singing the ministry’s tune. They insist the contracts were lawfully negotiated with the members, their parents and legal representatives, and contain protections for fundamental rights, including those guaranteed under the government-standard supplementary agreement for minors.
The controversy has revived attention on South Korea’s standard exclusive contracts, first introduced in 2009 to clean up unfair practices. They have been revised over the years, with extra agreements for minors, but the question remains: does the framework reflect today’s K-pop reality? The Popular Culture and Arts Industry Development Act requires agencies to safeguard underage performers’ physical and mental health, education, personal rights, sleep, rest and freedom of choice. It restricts late-night entertainment activities by minors, sets age-based working-hour limits with certain exceptions, and prohibits interference with education.
Yet the urgency is obvious. Agencies are debuting idols younger and younger. A2O Lite, the nine-member girl group under A2O Entertainment-founded by former SM Entertainment chief Lee Soo-man-has topped Melon’s Top 100 with its debut single Neon. All nine members are minors, including three aged 13. A2O Soul, a 15-member boy group under the same agency that debuted alongside A2O Lite in October, has 13 underage members.
The camera loves youth. The question is whether the contracts do. Stay tuned.