SC Judge Ujjal Bhuyan: Punishing Students for Questions Unconstitutional
New Delhi, Aug 30: Supreme Court judge Ujjal Bhuyan on Sunday told graduating postgraduates at the 13th convocation of National Law University, Delhi, that students who express dissenting views or ask questions must not be threatened with punishment, calling such measures unconstitutional and a misuse of authority.
Bhuyan said universities should be spaces where “established positions” can be examined and challenged, and where the habit of free thinking begins. He stressed that the right to ask difficult questions is not an act of defiance, and warned that “an intolerant mind” runs counter to the spirit of the Indian Constitution.
Addressing the graduates, he warned plainly: “When students express a different point of view, when students ask questions, they cannot be threatened with punitive action.” He added, “That is unconstitutional. That is a misuse of power and office.”
Bhuyan argued that campuses must encourage reasoned disagreement rather than hostility, since a democratic society that respects liberty and difference needs that culture to start at universities. He said the Constitution recognises that a free society will contain diverse opinions and that meaningful public participation requires space for dissent.
Recalling India’s tradition of nonviolence and tolerance, Bhuyan described tolerance as a constitutional value and said the country had no place for intolerance, which he characterised as a form of violence. He urged that when dissent is treated as something to be silenced, the constitutional framework protecting freedom of speech, thought and belief begins to erode.
He concluded by urging legal professionals and scholars to uphold the constitutional values of liberty, equality, dignity and justice, ensuring those principles remain central even amid disagreement.
PTI
Original Source: https://assamtribune.com/national/punishing-students-for-asking-questions-is-unconstitutional-sc-judge-ujjal-bhuyan-1616309
Category: National,Featured
Tags:
Publish Date: 2026-08-30 13:49:00