২২ হাজাৰ কোটি ঋণ মাত্ৰ ৬.৫ কোটিত নিষ্পত্তি — সুভাষ চন্দ্ৰ NCLT সিদ্ধান্ত ঘিরে বিতৰ্ক
Zee Group founder Subhash Chandra’s personal insolvency case has ignited fresh controversy after a National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) panel approved a repayment plan under which lenders’ recognised claims of ₹22,206.57 crore would be met with only about ₹6.5 crore in recoveries — roughly 3 paise for every ₹100 owed. The NCLT approval effectively requires creditors to accept an estimated 99.97% haircut on their claims, a figure that has prompted sharp objections from several lenders and legal commentators.
Under the sanctioned plan, creditors voted in favour by a wide margin: representatives holding 80.81% of the voting rights backed the proposal, while opposing votes accounted for less than 20% of the total. A two-member NCLT bench was divided on the matter and the case was referred to a third member, Justice Nilesh Sharma, who authorised the plan under Section 114 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). The tribunal reasoned that if a proposal is within the legal framework, the court should not substitute its own commercial judgment for that of the majority of creditors; the tribunal’s role is to ensure compliance with law and procedure, not to reassess commercial viability.
Several lenders opposed the proposal on substantive and procedural grounds. LIC Housing Finance — a major creditor with a recognised claim of about ₹1,322.39 crore — said the plan would yield only around ₹38 lakh for the firm and labeled the arrangement unrealistic, also questioning its legality. Other dissenting creditors noted that the ₹6.5 crore figure appears to be a contingent or prospective amount rather than an assured sum, and therefore argued it is inappropriate to accept such an uncertain recovery against such large claims.
The dispute stems from personal guarantees Subhash Chandra provided for loans taken by a firm called Vivek Infrakon, which borrowed about ₹170 crore. After loan default, Indiabulls Housing Finance (now renamed Sammaan Capital) initiated proceedings against Chandra in 2022. The NCLT accepted the insolvency application in April 2024. Earlier settlement attempts failed, and following the Supreme Court’s November 2023 endorsement of key IBC provisions, insolvency action restarted in February 2024.
The NCLT also observed that Chandra’s personal assets and financial resources appear to be valued at less than the proposed ₹6.5 crore recovery, and that declaring him insolvent could yield even lower returns for creditors. Still, legal experts remain divided: some warn that allowing such extensive write-downs based on majority creditor votes could set a troubling precedent for future personal insolvency cases. With the case now expected to move to a Division Bench for formal directions, the decision raises broader questions about creditor protection, commercial valuation, and the future trajectory of India’s insolvency regime.
Original Source: https://assam.nenow.in/%E2%82%B922000-crore-debt-settled-for-just-%E2%82%B96-5-crore-controversy-erupts-over-nclt-decision-in-subhash-chandras-personal-insolvency-proceedings/
Category: দেশ,শীর্ষ সংবাদ
Tags:
Publish Date: 2026-08-28 07:00:00